Dairy Never Cared

Saw you sittin' there in the fridge light glow White lies in a carton, heart sayin' no I knew better but I reached inside Now I'm payin' for it deep down inside You taste like comfort, feel like home But every time I'm left alone With consequences I can't deny... Why do I keep comin' back, oh why You're bad for me but I still believe In the fantasy of mac and cheese Every time I swear we're through Then you melt my heart like fondue do You tear me up inside, it's true But I still come runnin' back to you Love shouldn't hurt the way you do But baby... dairy never cared, did you Late night whisper of a cheesy slice You say "just one bite" like that's advice You pull me in with that melted guise Now I'm curled up rethinking my life We had history, we had taste Now it's pain I can't outpace Should've known from the very start You were trouble for my fragile heart You're bad for me but I still believe In the fairy tale of fettuccine Every time I say "I'm done" You show up lookin' like ice cream love You tear me up inside, it's true Still I come runnin' back to you This relationship's overdue But baby... dairy never cared, did you I tried almond I tried oat But your memory still floats In my coffee... in my dreams... Why you gotta haunt my dairy free schemes? I should walk away for good But you taste too good... like you always would... You're bad for me but I still believe In forbidden bowls of ricotta dreams Every time I break away You come back as three cheese lasagna bae You tear me up inside, it's true But I still come runnin' back to you Love shouldn't need a rescue crew But baby... dairy never cared... No dairy never cared... No dairy never cared... About my digestive truth