
One look, and suddenly leaving doesn’t feel like such a good idea.
“There’s That Smile” is about getting pulled back toward someone you know you probably shouldn’t overthink. He starts the night ready to leave, already tired of the noise around him, until one familiar smile completely changes his mood. Every time he thinks he understands what’s happening between them, she shifts again—close one moment, distant the next. Instead of trying to solve it, he slowly gives in to the confusion and lets himself enjoy being caught in the groove with her. It’s playful, flirty, and slightly unsure: that moment when you know someone is messing with your head a little, but you keep coming back anyway.
[Intro] Hey come on Oh-oh yeah [Verse 1] Here we are again Everybody talking like they know the score Someone wins someone disappears Nobody asks what we came here for I was halfway out the door Then you turned and caught my eye Now I'm standing here forgetting why I wanted to leave tonight [Pre-Chorus] You pull me in then let me go I lose my place but somehow know Every time I think I'm through I end up right next to you [Chorus] So confused when I'm caught in the groove Don't know what you're trying to prove One little look and I change my mind I was doing fine till you crossed that line Caught in the groove Caught up in you I don't know what you're gonna do But if you're staying stay for a while Come a little closer don't make me guess by that smile [Post-Chorus] Oh-oh-oh caught in the groove Yeah-yeah caught up in you [Verse 2] Downtown rolls around Same old faces wearing something new You change colours every time I turn I never know which side is you You catch me when I'm falling Then you leave me off my feet Say we're nothing then you find me every time we happen to meet [Pre-Chorus] You pull me in then let me go I should know better by now, I know Every time I think I'm through I end up right next to you [Chorus] So confused when I'm caught in the groove Don't know what you're trying to prove One little look and I change my mind I was doing fine till you crossed that line Caught in the groove Caught up in you I don't know what you're gonna do But if you're staying stay for a while Come a little closer don't make me guess by that smile Come on [Trumpet R] Not again You know exactly what you're doing [Bridge] Maybe I don't need to figure you out Maybe tonight that's not what this is about You take one step I take two Somehow I keep ending up with you So if we're going nowhere fast Maybe that's okay Don't tell me where this ends Just don't walk away [Final Chorus] So confused when I'm caught in the groove Still don't know what you're trying to prove One little look and I lose my mind Maybe I don't mind crossing that line Caught in the groove Caught up in you Maybe I know what I wanna do If you're staying stay for a while Come a little closer yeah— there's that smile [Final Post-Chorus] Caught in the groove Oh-oh caught up in you Caught in the groove Yeah-yeah I keep coming back to you [Outro] So confused... but maybe— I like it